FEMH Magazine

:::
  • 2026-01-15

Shattering Common Myths: Four Medical Truths About Hernias You Should Know

Department of General Surgery Dr. Tiing-Foong Siow
PIC

Hernia Specialist / Attending Surgeon

A Hernia Is Not Just a “Simple Hole”

         Many people believe that a hernia is merely a “hole in the abdomen” that can be repaired later without urgency. In fact, a hernia is defined as the protrusion of intra-abdominal organs or tissues through a weakened area of the abdominal wall muscle or fascia, extending to the body surface or into another anatomical compartment.
The most common locations include the groin (inguinal hernia), the umbilicus (umbilical hernia), and previous surgical scars (incisional hernia).

     A hernia is not merely a cosmetic issue. If neglected, it may lead to bowel compression, compromised blood supply, and even intestinal necrosis. Hernia progression is not random—it is driven by well-defined physical forces.


Truth #1: Hernias Enlarge Over Time—This Is Governed by the Laws of Physics

         The abdominal cavity functions much like a pressure vessel. According to Pascal’s principle, increases in intra-abdominal pressure—such as during coughing, lifting heavy objects, or straining during defecation—are transmitted evenly throughout the abdominal wall. When a weak point exists, pressure becomes concentrated at that site, leading to tissue protrusion and hernia formation.PIC

         Furthermore, Laplace’s law explains that as the radius of a protrusion increases, the wall tension also increases, progressively enlarging the defect. This is why hernias do not heal spontaneously; instead, they continue to grow over time.

For this reason, surgeons strongly advise early medical evaluation once a hernia is detected, to prevent incarceration or strangulation that may result in bowel necrosis.


Truth #2: The Most Dangerous Hernias May Not Cause Bowel Obstruction Symptoms

        Most people associate bowel incarceration with severe abdominal pain and vomiting. However, Richter’s hernia is a particularly deceptive and dangerous condition. In this type of hernia, only a portion of the bowel wall is trapped, allowing intestinal contents to continue passing through. As a result, classic symptoms of bowel obstruction may be absent.

         Despite minimal symptoms, compromised blood flow can rapidly lead to bowel necrosis. Richter’s hernia occurs more frequently in elderly women, often at the femoral canal. Externally, it may appear as a small lump and is easily mistaken for an enlarged lymph node.

           If localized pain, redness, or fever develops, immediate medical attention is crucial. Delayed diagnosis may result in bowel perforation and sepsis.


Truth #3: Not Every Abdominal Bulge Is a Hernia

         A midline abdominal bulge is not always caused by a hernia. It may instead represent rectus abdominis diastasis, a condition in which the abdominal muscles are stretched apart due to pregnancy, obesity, or aging—without an actual fascial defect.

        Although rectus diastasis may resemble a hernia externally, no intra-abdominal contents protrude through the abdominal wall. Surgery is usually unnecessary; however, if an umbilical hernia is present concurrently, surgical evaluation is warranted.

        Accurate diagnosis prevents unnecessary operations and allows for appropriate management, including targeted core muscle training or rehabilitation.


Truth #4: One in Two People May Have an Umbilical Hernia

       Umbilical hernias are far more common than most people realize. Studies report a prevalence ranging from 23% to 50% in adults. The condition is three times more common in women than in men, and during pregnancy, increased intra-abdominal pressure means that nearly all women develop some degree of umbilical herniation.

        Most umbilical hernias are small and reducible, requiring only observation. However, if the bulge becomes irreducible, painful, or discolored, it indicates incarceration and urgent surgical intervention is required.


Modern Surgical Treatment of Hernias

         Hernia surgery has evolved from traditional open repair to minimally invasive and robotic-assisted techniques. The primary goals are defect repair, restoration of abdominal wall integrity, and reduction of recurrence risk.

1. Open Repair
         An incision is made over the hernia site, the protruding contents are reduced into the abdominal cavity, and a synthetic mesh is placed to reinforce the weakened area. This approach is suitable for large or complex hernias but is associated with a longer recovery period.

2. Laparoscopic Repair
      Through several small incisions, a camera and instruments are inserted to repair the hernia from within the abdominal cavity or preperitoneal space. This technique offers less postoperative pain, faster recovery, and improved cosmetic outcomes, and is widely used today.

3. Robotic-Assisted Repair (Da Vinci System)
         Robotic surgery provides three-dimensional visualization and enhanced precision, making it particularly suitable for complex or recurrent hernias. Surgeons can perform meticulous tissue dissection and optimal mesh placement, resulting in reduced postoperative pain and lower recurrence rates.

       Regardless of the surgical approach, patients should avoid premature heavy lifting, maintain a healthy body weight, and manage chronic cough or constipation to minimize the risk of recurrence.


Conclusion: Listen to Subtle Signals from Your Body

         Although hernias may appear minor, they can conceal serious risks. If you notice a recurrent bulge in the abdomen or groin—especially one that becomes more prominent with straining—seek prompt evaluation by a qualified surgeon.

        Modern hernia surgery is safe, effective, and associated with rapid recovery. Early treatment not only prevents complications but also restores quality of life.

“Do not wait for a hernia to heal on its own—because it never will.”
         This simple yet crucial advice from surgeons may be the key to protecting your long-term health.